Giving helpful feedback on writing

The purpose is to help the writer improve her/his story by identifying what works well and what doesn’t.

In my writing group, each writer sends a list of queries to the group along with her story. These vary depending on the stage of development of the story, the particular challenges in the story, and the strengths or weaknesses of the writer.

This is how we do it:

1. Cone of silence.

The author is surrounded by a cone of silence and cannot comment on the feedback. The readers discuss the story as if the writer is not present.

2. Summary or What the story is really about.

One reader volunteers to summarize the story in 1-2 sentences. This helps clarify whether the narrative is clear or not. When the reader is done, we ask if everyone agrees. If not, an additional reader (or two) summarizes the story. If everyone is on the same page, this confirms for the writer what the story is about. If the author doesn’t agree with the summary, then this helps identify a disconnect between the author’s intent and the reader’s understanding.

3. What works.

Each reader, in turn, identifies the main items in the story that work. The narrative arc, the dialogue, characters’ three-dimensionality, the mood etc. We keep it on the page by providing examples or illustrations from the text.

4. What doesn’t work.

Each reader identifies the items with which she had difficulty (not believable, confusing, transitions etc.) and explain why. Again, we keep it on the page by providing examples or illustrations from the text.

“It just isn’t believable,” doesn’t cut it. Why isn’t it believable? Where isn’t it believable? Why and where is it believable? Again keep it on the page.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Body by Basch

Living & Loving My Life


Many physicists today postulate the existence of multiple universes, even when sober. We used to live in a world of infinite possibilities. Now we live in an infinite number of worlds. India shines. Democracy thrives. The economy booms. A hundred flyovers bloom. This is not that India. If you see your picture here one day, don’t worry. That’s not you.

Building an Everyday Life

finding supports for an adult disabled daughter

The Golden Antlers

The 5Cs' only source of news. Ever.

bits & pieces

life as I see it

Bathurst Muses

Writing Groups Demystified

%d bloggers like this: